As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links to Amazon on this page are affiliate links.
Basket, dual-basket or oven-style?
Updated
Pick a single basket if you cook for one to three and want the least fuss. Pick a dual basket if you always make a main and a side. Pick an oven-style model if you feed four or more, or you want it to replace your toaster. The rest of this page is the reasoning.
Side by side
| Single basket | Dual basket | Oven-style | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Example here | COSORI TurboBlaze 6 Qt | Ninja DualZone DZ201 | Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro |
| Cooking floor | About 87 sq in (listing) | Two floors of about 58 sq in each (my estimate) | Up to about 216 sq in (listing interior) |
| Counter footprint | About 170 sq in | About 217 sq in | About 376 sq in |
| Weight | 13.2 lb | 17.86 lb | 30.2 lb |
| Shaking food | Pull the basket and shake | Same, twice | Open the door and turn food with tongs |
| Two foods at once | Only if they share a time and temperature | Yes, that is the design | Yes on one tray, at one temperature |
| Uses normal pans | No | No | Yes. The Breville listing says most 9 x 13 inch pans fit |
| Cleanup | One basket, one plate | Two baskets, two plates | Trays, racks, a mesh basket and the oven walls |
Single basket
A drawer with a handle. Hot air comes down from the top, and the small space is why it cooks fast. It is the simplest type to use and to clean. The limit is the floor. For one layer foods, a 6 quart basket suits two people by my math on the size page. The basket picks here are the COSORI TurboBlaze, the Ninja Air Fryer Pro, the Instant Vortex XL and, for one person, the Chefman TurboFry Touch.
Dual basket
Two small air fryers in one body. The Ninja DZ201 listing says each 4 quart zone has its own fan and heater. Smart Finish holds back the faster food so both end together. Match Cook runs both sides the same. Owners like exactly that. The catch is that neither floor is big. If you often cook one large thing, a dual basket is the wrong shape.
Oven-style
A countertop oven with a strong fan and an air fry setting. Food sits on a mesh basket or tray. You get far more floor, and you can see the food through the door. You give up counter space and some speed. The Breville's review summary has mixed reports on preheat time, with some owners calling it slow. A small basket unit has much less air to heat. Instant says its basket model needs little to no preheating, and COSORI makes preheat optional.
How much of the counter turns into cooking floor?
This one surprised me. For the COSORI, the listed cooking floor is about 51 percent of the counter it takes up. For the Instant it is about 47 percent. For the Breville, the interior is about 57 percent of its footprint. So the oven-style model is big, but it does not waste more counter than a basket does. It just asks for a lot of counter in one piece.
Which I'd choose
- One or two people, small kitchen: single basket.
- Three people: a 6 quart basket if you mostly do fries, vegetables and reheating. A dual basket if dinner is usually a protein plus a side.
- Four or more: oven-style, if you have the counter. Check that first on the counter and power page.
All six picks, with specs and owner feedback, are on the shortlist.